Culture & Arts

The Nexus of Abolition, Religion, and Black Heritage

Plymouth Church, Bridge Street AWME Church and Weeksville made Brooklyn a vital center of abolitionism and Black community building.

4 min read

Brooklyn holds a preeminent, though frequently under-examined, place in the history of African American liberation and community building. Prior to the Civil War, the borough served as a vital hub for abolitionist activity and the Underground Railroad, facilitated largely by its expansive waterfront, its population of free Black citizens, and the moral conviction of radical religious congregations.

Plymouth Church and Radical Abolition

Located on Orange Street in Brooklyn Heights, Plymouth Church stands as one of the most significant sites of American abolitionism. Founded in 1847 by twenty-one New England congregationalists—including wealthy anti-slavery merchants like Arthur and Lewis Tappan—the church called upon Henry Ward Beecher as its first minister. Beecher, the brother of Uncle Tom's Cabin author Harriet Beecher Stowe, utilized a flamboyant, colloquial oratory style to denounce the institution of slavery, transforming Plymouth Church into a national epicenter for the abolitionist movement.20,22

Plymouth Church functioned as a highly active, covert stop on the Underground Railroad, earning the moniker of the "Grand Central Depot" among abolitionist networks. Fugitive slaves seeking passage to Canada were frequently hidden in the church's tunnel-like basement and cavernous, brick-arched undercroft. As Beecher’s private stenographer recorded, the minister explicitly acknowledged this activity, stating, "I piloted them, and sent them toward the North Star, which to them was the Star of Bethlehem". The Reverend Charles B. Ray, an African American newspaper editor residing in Manhattan, corroborated this network, noting he regularly transported fugitives directly to Beecher's church.21,22,23,24

I piloted them, and sent them toward the North Star, which to them was the Star of Bethlehem

Henry Ward Beecher, as recorded by his private stenographer

Beecher also mastered the art of political theater to sway public opinion and generate abolitionist funding. He famously staged "mock slave auctions" directly from the church’s raised pulpit. In these highly emotional events, Beecher would present enslaved individuals—such as a young girl known as "Pinky"—and appeal to the 2,000-person congregation to donate the funds necessary to purchase their legal freedom. Historical artifacts from these events, including Pinky's ring, remain preserved in the church's historical gallery.21,22

Photograph of Plymouth Church
Suggested photo: Plymouth Church on Orange Street, Brooklyn Heights.

The church's cultural gravity drew prominent figures spanning centuries. Abraham Lincoln worshipped there in February 1860, and a silver plaque currently marks pew 89 where he sat. An array of literary and political luminaries, including Mark Twain, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Walt Whitman, and Clara Barton, spoke at Plymouth, and in early 1963, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. delivered an early iteration of his "I Have a Dream" speech to the congregation. Architecturally designed by Joseph C. Wells in an urban tabernacle style to optimize acoustics and line-of-sight for preaching, the church retains its original pews, an immense 1866 pipe organ installed by E. and G. G. Hook, a lectern constructed from olive wood acquired during an 1867 Holy Land expedition, and stunning stained glass windows installed between 1907 and 1909 by J&R Lamb Studios that depict figures like Harriet Beecher Stowe and the founding of New England colleges. A statue of Beecher by sculptor Gutzon Borglum currently resides in the church garden, memorializing his legacy.20,26

Bridge Street AWME Church

Pre-dating Plymouth by nearly a century, the Bridge Street African Wesleyan Methodist Episcopal (AWME) Church is the oldest African American congregation in the Brooklyn and Long Island area, tracing its origins to 1766. The congregation grew significantly in the nineteenth century, culminating in the 1854 purchase of a red brick building at 309 Bridge Street, a structure previously occupied by the First Congregational Church. As an independent Black church, Bridge Street served as an indispensable sanctuary and organizing space for the free Black community, harboring self-emancipated individuals and providing essential spiritual and social refuge during the antebellum period. The historic building on Bridge Street survives today as the Wunsch Building, serving as the admissions office for New York University's Polytechnic Institute.27,30

Weeksville Heritage Center

Further east, in what encompasses modern-day Crown Heights and Bedford-Stuyvesant, the settlement of Weeksville represents one of America's first and most significant free Black communities. Established in the nineteenth century, Weeksville was a thriving, self-sufficient neighborhood that prioritized Black entrepreneurship, education, and political enfranchisement in an era defined by disenfranchisement.31,33

Today, the legacy of this settlement is fiercely protected by the Weeksville Heritage Center, a multidimensional museum centered around four historic Hunterfly Road Houses that survive on their original foundations, providing a tangible link to the daily lives of the community's nineteenth-century residents. The Center operates a 19,000-square-foot LEED Gold-certified building, utilizing art, education, and a contemporary social justice framework to connect the historical struggle for Black liberation with current sociopolitical realities. Through exhibitions, public art, urban farming markets, and ecological programs, Weeksville underscores the fact that Black cultural heritage in Brooklyn is not a relic of the past, but an enduring, living narrative that actively shapes current and future generations.33,31

Photograph of the Hunterfly Road Houses
Suggested photo: the Hunterfly Road Houses at the Weeksville Heritage Center.

Sources cited in this chapter

  1. Plymouth Church (Brooklyn) - Wikipedia ↗
  2. More History — Plymouth Church ↗
  3. Plymouth Church Brooklyn, Henry Ward Beecher and the Civil War ↗
  4. Exploring the Underground Railroad, in Brooklyn - Atlas Obscura ↗
  5. Underground Railroad - Brooklyn - Plymouth Church ↗
  6. Plymouth Church and Henry Ward Beecher - Mille Fiori Favoriti ↗
  7. Bridge Street African Wesleyan Methodist Episcopal Church ↗
  8. BRIDGE STREET AME CELEBRATES 250 BLESSED YEARS ↗
  9. About Us - Weeksville Heritage Center ↗
  10. Weeksville Heritage Center ↗

Share this site

Send this page to a friend, or let someone scan the code with their phone.

↑